Summary
Winfield Scott School No. 2 is a 630-student PK–8 school at 125 Madison Ave. in Elizabeth, part of Elizabeth Public Schools, with 10 nearby schools in the comparison group, all in the same district. Its latest averages across the grades reported were 25% in English Language Arts (ELA), 18% in math, 10% in Algebra I and 3% in science. The main takeaway is a generally weak academic profile compared with nearby schools, despite a notable bright spot in sixth-grade ELA.
Sixth-grade ELA is a clear strength: 38% of students were proficient, compared with 35% in the district, 51% statewide and 24% at nearby schools on average—the highest nearby result. Overall ELA was close to the nearby average, at 25% versus 25%, but below district and state averages of 35% and 51%. Math was weaker, at 18% versus 23% nearby, 31% in the district and 44% statewide. Algebra I shows the largest nearby-school gap: 10% proficient, compared with 17% nearby, 22% in the district and 40% statewide. Science was also low at 3%, versus 6% nearby, 11% in the district and 23% statewide.
Results over time are mixed: from 2022–2023 to 2025–2026, ELA fell by 4 percentage points and science by 4, while math rose by 1 point and Algebra I by 5; the state gaps widened in ELA, math and science. SchoolDigger ranks the school 1,215th of 1,331 New Jersey schools, at the 9th percentile with 0 stars; its percentile is fourth-lowest among nearby schools, whose results range from the 6th to the 21st percentile. The student–teacher ratio was 12.1 in 2024–2025, versus a nearby average of 12.6. In that same year, 82% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible, the lowest reported share among nearby schools, which averaged 87%. SchoolDigger’s statewide effectiveness rankings for English Language Learner Students (35th percentile) and African American Students (30th) are notably above its overall 9th-percentile ranking; the English Language Learner ranking rose from the 28th percentile in 2023–2024.
Thank you for your feedback!