Summary:
The seven schools in Hillside Public School District serve 2,957 students from prekindergarten through grade 12; six report test scores, while Abram P. Morris Early Childhood Center does not. Results vary sharply by school: Hillside Innovation Academy is far ahead in middle-school English language arts (ELA), while elementary results generally fall below state rates, with math the clearest broad concern. In 2025–2026, the three tested elementary schools averaged 26% in math across grades 3–6, compared with 46% statewide; the most important takeaway is that a district-wide picture hides substantial differences between schools and subjects.
Innovation is the clearest standout: its grade 7 and 8 ELA proficiency was 79% and 85%, compared with 56% and 53% statewide. By contrast, Walter O. Krumbiegel Middle School scored 33% and 36% in those grades—23 and 18 points below state rates. Among the elementary schools, Hurden Looker Elementary School led in ELA grades 4–6 and math grades 5–6, while Deanna G. Taylor Academy led in grade 3 ELA and math but had the lowest grade 4 ELA and math scores. Algebra I end-of-course results were another bright spot for Innovation and Krumbiegel, at 68% and 71% versus 40% statewide; Hillside High School scored 4%.
Elementary results weakened overall from 2024–2025: the group’s average ELA score fell from 48% to 38%, and its math average from 29% to 26%; the math gap with the state widened from 16 to 20 points. There are exceptions, including Taylor’s 2-point gain in average math, though its grade 4 math score fell 12 points. SchoolDigger ranks Innovation at the 59th percentile with 3 stars in 2025–2026, down from the 75th percentile and 4 stars in 2023–2024; the district ranks 510 of 607, at the 16th percentile with 1 star. Reported student-teacher ratios range from 10.1 at Taylor to 16.1 at Innovation. For 2024–2025, the six schools reporting free/reduced lunch eligibility had shares from 67% at Hillside High to 83% at Ola Edwards; these figures offer context, not an explanation for school results.
Thank you for your feedback!