Best Middle Schools in Cape May, NJ

The city of Cape May, New Jersey is home to two middle schools: Richard M. Teitelman Middle School and Sandman Consolidated School. These schools serve students in grades 5-8 and are part of the Lower Cape May Regional School District and the Lower Township Elementary School District, respectively.

Richard M. Teitelman Middle School stands out for its exceptional performance in Algebra I, with 93.5% of 8th grade students proficient or better in 2024-2025, significantly higher than the state average of 72.7%. However, the school has consistently ranked in the bottom half of New Jersey middle schools, suggesting room for improvement in other subject areas. Sandman Consolidated School, on the other hand, has higher English Language Arts proficiency rates for 6th grade students compared to the district and state, but lower proficiency rates in most other subjects, indicating a need to focus on improving academic outcomes, especially in math and science, for these younger middle school grades.

Both schools face challenges, with higher-than-average chronic absenteeism rates of 14.9% in 2023-2024, which is an area that warrants further investigation. Additionally, the significant difference in per-student spending between the two schools, with Richard M. Teitelman Middle School spending $14,823 per student and Sandman Consolidated School spending $12,054 per student, is noteworthy and may be an opportunity to explore more equitable funding allocation.