Summary:
The Simpson County School District in Mississippi includes three elementary schools—Mendenhall Elementary School, Magee Elementary School, and Simpson Central School—serving grades PK through 8 in a high-poverty area where 84% to 92% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
Simpson Central School is the district's clear standout. It holds the highest ranking at the 34th percentile with 2 stars, while Mendenhall Elementary School ranks at the 21st percentile and Magee Elementary School at the 16th. Simpson Central excels particularly in math, with 5th grade proficiency at 68.8%—30 points above the district average and nearly 20 points above the state—and it posts the healthiest chronic absenteeism rate at 21.7%, below the state average of 23.9%. Mendenhall Elementary School, the largest school with 598 students, shows bright spots in 4th grade ELA (50.8%) and 5th grade science (62.4%) but struggles significantly in 6th grade. Magee Elementary School, with the highest poverty rate at 92% and the highest student-teacher ratio at 17.0, remains the lowest-ranked school, though its 3rd grade math slightly exceeds the district average.
Chronic absenteeism is a major district-wide concern. The district rate of 41.0% far exceeds the state average, and only Simpson Central keeps absenteeism at a healthy level. All three schools have trended downward in recent years—Simpson Central fell from the 58th to the 34th percentile, Magee dropped from the 30th to the 16th, and Mendenhall has remained low in the low-20s. That said, poverty does not fully explain performance. Simpson Central achieves strong results despite 84% free/reduced lunch eligibility, suggesting school-level practices matter. Upper-grade transitions are a common weakness across the district, particularly 6th grade at Mendenhall and 8th grade at Simpson Central. For parents, Simpson Central offers the strongest overall academic environment, while Mendenhall and Magee each have specific strengths worth exploring.
Thank you for your feedback!