Summary:
Zip code 49323, serving the Dorr, Michigan area, is home to two public elementary schools—Dorr School and Sycamore Elementary School—both serving grades PK-5 with a combined enrollment of just over 500 students.
For parents comparing these two schools, Sycamore Elementary School stands out as the more consistently high-performing option across all grade levels and subjects. It currently ranks in the 89th percentile statewide (4 stars) and posted a 96th percentile (5-star) ranking the previous year. Its test scores are well above state averages—for example, 5th-grade ELA proficiency is 75% versus the state's 43.8%, and 5th-grade math is 68.8% versus 32.2%. Sycamore also boasts an exceptionally low chronic absenteeism rate of just 5.7%, compared to the state average of 27.9%, and a favorable student-teacher ratio of 12.6. Meanwhile, Dorr School shows a remarkable "3rd-grade phenomenon" with 71% proficiency in both ELA and math—nearly double the state average—but its data is less current (its last state ranking was from 2018-19) and only covers 3rd grade, making it difficult to assess upper-grade performance. Dorr also has a higher chronic absenteeism rate (23.1%) and a larger student-teacher ratio (14.6).
Both schools belong to different districts: Wayland Union Schools (Dorr) and Hopkins Public Schools (Sycamore). Sycamore's scores consistently outpace its district, which itself appears strong, while Dorr is a "pocket of excellence" within a district closer to state averages. Notably, Sycamore achieves superior results while spending about $1,000 less per student than Dorr, suggesting greater efficiency. For parents prioritizing consistent, well-rounded academic success and strong attendance, Sycamore is the clear choice; for those focused on early-elementary excellence, Dorr's 3rd-grade results are exceptional, though its lack of recent data warrants caution.
Thank you for your feedback!