Summary:
The city of Dorr, Michigan, is served by two public elementary schools—Dorr School and Sycamore Elementary School—both educating students from Pre-Kindergarten through 5th grade, though they belong to different districts: Wayland Union Schools and Hopkins Public Schools, respectively.
For parents, the standout choice is clearly Sycamore Elementary School. It ranks in the 96th percentile statewide (64th out of 1,488 Michigan elementary schools) and holds a 5-star rating. Its academic performance is exceptional: 84.4% of 4th graders were proficient in math versus a 39.4% state average, and 5th grade science proficiency hit 68.4% compared to 40.3% statewide. Sycamore also posts a remarkably low chronic absenteeism rate of just 5.7%, far below the state average of 27.9% and its own district’s 13.6%. In contrast, Dorr School is a solid but less consistent performer. Its most recent ranking data is from 2018-2019 (90th percentile), and its chronic absenteeism rate is 23.1%—four times higher than Sycamore’s. Dorr’s 3rd grade proficiency rates (71% in both ELA and math) are above state averages but trail Sycamore’s 3rd grade ELA score of 77.1%.
Key differences extend beyond test scores. Sycamore has a lower student-teacher ratio (12.6 vs. 14.6) and a smaller share of students on free/reduced lunch (33.48% vs. 44.05%). Per-student spending is similar ($17,274 at Sycamore vs. $18,283 at Dorr), making Sycamore’s superior outcomes even more notable. One caveat: Dorr School’s data is incomplete—no recent rankings or upper-grade test scores are available—so parents may have less information to evaluate its current performance. Overall, while both schools serve the same community, Sycamore demonstrates consistent excellence across all subjects and grades, while Dorr offers adequate but less transparent results.
Thank you for your feedback!