Summary:
Carson City-Crystal Area Schools is home to a single middle school, Carson CityCrystal Upper ElementaryMiddle School, which serves grades 4 through 8 in a rural Michigan community with 262 students and a moderate-to-high level of economic need (54.2% free/reduced lunch eligibility).
Because this is the only middle school in the district, all comparisons are against state averages. The school’s biggest strength is 4th-grade math, where 44.8% of students were proficient in 2025-2026, beating the state average of 39.4% and representing the highest proficiency rate for any subject and grade in the school that year. However, this bright spot is offset by significant challenges elsewhere. The most alarming trend is a dramatic “5th-grade slump” in math, with proficiency crashing from 31.8% to just 19.3% in one year—a staggering 13 points below the state average. Science scores are also consistently weak, with 5th-grade proficiency at 24.6% and 8th-grade at 25.5%, both far below state averages of 40.0% and 39.2%, respectively. The school also shows a clear split between its upper elementary grades (4-5) and middle school grades (6-8), with 6th and 7th graders performing notably lower in both ELA and math.
Perhaps the most concerning issue is chronic absenteeism, which sits at 31.5%—well above the state average of 27.9%—meaning nearly one in three students is missing substantial school time. This likely drives much of the low academic performance. Additionally, 8th-grade PSAT scores are highly volatile: ELA proficiency swung from a near-state-average 61.4% down to 45.1%, while math fell from 25.0% to just 13.7%. The district spends a significant $13,782 per student, yet outcomes remain below state norms, suggesting resources may not be effectively targeted. For parents, this school offers a strong 4th-grade math program but requires careful attention to attendance, the 5th-grade transition, and middle school academic support.
Thank you for your feedback!