Summary:
Deer Isle-Stonington Central School District has two schools serving prekindergarten through grade 12: Deer Isle-Stonington Elementary School (PK–8) and Deer Isle-Stonington High School (grades 9–12), with 343 students combined. SchoolDigger ranks the district 103rd of 177 Maine districts, at the 42nd percentile with 2 stars. The most important takeaway is that the district-wide picture hides a sharp divide between the schools, especially in their latest SchoolDigger rankings and reported test results.
The high school stands out in the 2024–2025 tests, leading the elementary school in all three subjects: by 2 points in ELA (57% versus 55%), 25 points in math (52% versus 27%), and 9 points in science (25% versus 16%). The elementary school’s math result was the lowest reported school result in that year’s comparisons, 22 points below the state’s 49%; the high school was 3 points above the state. In 2025–2026, high school science remained a bright spot at 44%, 6 points above the state, while elementary ELA and math were 19 and 20 points below state results. SchoolDigger’s latest rankings also place the high school 22nd of 122 (82nd percentile, 4 stars) and the elementary school 274th of 281 (2nd percentile, 0 stars). High-school ELA and math results were not reported for 2025–2026, and the elementary school’s science result was suppressed.
Recent score trends are mixed: high school science rose 19 points, from 25% to 44%, and moved from 11 points below the state to 6 points above it. Elementary math increased 3 points, narrowing its state gap by 2 points, while its ELA score fell 10 points and its gap widened by 11 points. SchoolDigger’s percentile ranking rose 27 points for the high school from 2023–2024 to 2025–2026, while the elementary school’s fell 4 points. In 2024–2025, student-teacher ratios were 8.0 at the high school and 9.1 at the elementary school; free/reduced lunch eligible students were 49% and 59%, respectively. These are contextual differences, not explanations for the schools’ results. High school chronic absenteeism is also worth noting: 36% in 2025–2026, compared with 20% statewide, versus 24% at the elementary school.
Thank you for your feedback!