Summary:
Zip code 21703 in Frederick, Maryland, is home to six elementary schools serving grades PK-5 (with one exception) within the Frederick County Public Schools district, a 4-star rated system, and these schools reveal a striking performance and socioeconomic divide.
Orchard Grove Elementary stands out as the highest-performing school, ranking 253rd in the state with a 4-star rating and exceeding the district average in math proficiency. It is a notable "anomaly" because it achieves strong results despite having a majority of students on free/reduced lunch. In contrast, Hillcrest Elementary is the lowest-performing school, ranking 629th with a 1-star rating and the lowest test scores across nearly every metric, including critically low 5th-grade science proficiency. Carroll Creek Montessori Public Charter offers a unique PK-8 Montessori model and achieves exceptional middle school results, with 8th-grade ELA proficiency far above district averages, while also having the lowest chronic absenteeism rate at just 6.2%. Tuscarora Elementary leads in math proficiency but has the highest chronic absenteeism rate, while Ballenger Creek Elementary and Butterfly Ridge Elementary fall in the middle of the pack.
A key takeaway is that higher per-student spending does not guarantee success; Hillcrest spends the most ($24,563 per student) yet performs the worst, while Carroll Creek spends the least ($14,857) and achieves strong results. Socioeconomic status appears to be the strongest predictor of performance, with schools serving fewer students on free/reduced lunch generally outperforming those with higher poverty rates. Chronic absenteeism also emerges as a critical indicator, as the school with the lowest rate (Carroll Creek) is among the highest-performing, while the school with the highest rate (Tuscarora) has seen its state ranking decline.
Thank you for your feedback!