Summary:
Salem, Massachusetts has 11 schools enrolling 4,205 students, ranging from PK–5 and K–5 elementary schools through one middle school and four high schools, split between Salem (10 schools, 3,725 students, about 89% of the city) and Salem Academy Charter (District) (one school, 480 students). The four "high schools" vary enormously in size — from Salem High at 952 students to Salem Prep High School at 23 — a difference of more than 40x.
If you are comparing schools, Salem Academy Charter School is the clear academic leader, beating the state in ELA, science and 8th-grade civics and posting 95.6% graduation with 0.0% dropout. Among the traditional elementaries, Carlton is strongest and the only district elementary to top the state in any all-grades subject, while Bates gets the best elementary math (38.55) at the city's lowest per-student spending ($18,948). Witchcraft Heights also outperforms in math. By contrast, Bentley Academy Innovation School (8th percentile, all-grades math 9.6%), Horace Mann Laboratory (16th percentile, though improving), and New Liberty Innovation School (23.1% dropout) face the biggest challenges. Collins Middle improved from the 23rd to 34th percentile.
Citywide, mathematics is the structural weak point: the district trails the state by 15.7 points in math versus 9.7 in ELA, and 3rd-grade math ranges from 2.5% at Bentley to 43.24% at Saltonstall School. Spending does not track outcomes, and free/reduced-lunch data is blank for all 11 schools, so no poverty-adjusted comparison is possible.
Thank you for your feedback!