Summary:
Zip code 42167 has four Monroe County schools serving elementary through high school, with 1,602 students across Tompkinsville Elementary, Joe Harrison Carter, Monroe County Middle and Monroe County High. The strongest state-relative results are at the elementary schools, while the middle and high school results are mostly below state averages. Overall, the main finding is that student results vary considerably by school, grade and subject—notably, the elementary strengths do not carry consistently into middle and high school.
Tompkinsville Elementary stands out in the available results: its average was 20 percentage points above the state across five results, and its grade-5 social studies score was 84%, 46 points above state. Joe Harrison Carter averaged 12 points above state across nine results, including 70% in grade-3 math, 27 points above state. The elementary schools also show a sharp same-grade contrast: in grade-5 social studies, Tompkinsville scored 84% and Joe Harrison Carter 28%, a 56-point difference. At the other end, Monroe County Middle averaged 5 points below state and Monroe County High averaged 8 points below. These averages combine different grades and subjects, so they are not a like-for-like ranking.
Across 28 results matched between the two school years, the average state-relative gap narrowed from 6 points above state in 2024–25 to 4 points above in 2025–26, a 2-point decline. Monroe County Middle was an exception, moving 1 point closer to state on average; the other schools moved farther away. SchoolDigger ranks Tompkinsville Elementary at the 87th percentile and Joe Harrison Carter at the 74th, compared with the 38th for the middle school and 26th for the high school. The high school combines a 99% graduation rate with 34% chronic absenteeism, above the state’s 24%. For context, 2024–25 free/reduced lunch eligibility ranged from 66% at Joe Harrison Carter to 75% at Tompkinsville; student–teacher ratios ranged from 13.4 to 17.9.
Thank you for your feedback!