Summary:
The four public schools in Carroll County serve students from kindergarten through grade 12, from Kathryn Winn Primary (K–1) to Carroll County High School (9–12). The available 2025–2026 test results cover three schools; Kathryn Winn has no test scores in this data. Across 25 reported grade-and-subject results, every school result was below the matching state result, by an average of 17 points. This broad pattern is the clearest academic concern across the area.
Carroll County High School stands out as the strongest of the tested schools relative to state results: its six scores averaged 26% proficient, compared with 39% for the matching state results, a 13-point gap. Its individual gaps ranged from 8 to 19 points. The widest average gap was at Carroll County Middle School, at 19 points; Cartmell Elementary averaged an 18-point gap. Some specific results were further below state levels: middle-school fifth-grade reading was 25 points lower, and Cartmell fourth-grade science was 24 points lower. School averages cover different grades and subjects, so they are not direct like-for-like comparisons.
Across the same 25 results, the average gap narrowed from 19 points in 2024–2025 to 17 in 2025–2026, though progress varied: Cartmell fourth-grade math narrowed its gap from 24 to 15 points, while middle-school fifth-grade reading widened from 21 to 25. Attendance offers another point of comparison: Cartmell’s chronic absenteeism was 16%, below the state’s 24%, while the high school’s was 31%, above it. SchoolDigger ranked the high school in the 17th percentile (1 star), the middle school in the 6th (0 stars), and Cartmell in the 7th (0 stars). For 2024–2025, all four schools reported free/reduced lunch eligible figures, ranging from 51% at the high school to 64% at Kathryn Winn; these are context, not an explanation of results. Student-teacher ratios ranged from 14.5 at Cartmell to 20.6 at the high school.
Thank you for your feedback!