Summary:
Zip code 67732 has two schools: Brewster Elementary serves PK–5 with 90 students, and Brewster High serves grades 6–12 with 34 students; no separate middle school is listed. Their 2025–26 all-grades results put elementary ahead in both ELA, 41% versus 20%, and math, 41% versus 24%. The most important concern is at the high school: chronic absenteeism is 40%, compared with 18% statewide, while graduation is 70% versus 90% statewide and the dropout rate is 24% versus 1%.
Brewster Elementary is the stronger of the two on the reported all-grades tests, although its results remain just below the state in ELA: 41% versus 46%; in math, its 40.7% is close to the state’s 41.0%. Its third graders stand out positively, scoring 60% in ELA and 50% in math, 8 and 7 points above state results. Fourth-grade results are a clear exception: 27% in both subjects, 23 points below the state in ELA and 17 points below in math. Brewster High is the weaker test-score performer and has the attendance and completion concerns noted above.
Elementary test results improved from 2024–25 to 2025–26: ELA and math each rose about 10 points, narrowing the state gap from 13 points to 5 in ELA and from 8 points to 0.3 in math. SchoolDigger gives elementary a 37th-percentile ranking and 2 stars for 2025–26; its ranking history rose from the 8th percentile in 2021–22. The latest supplied SchoolDigger ranking for high school is older, from 2022–23: 4th percentile and 0 stars. The schools have similar student-teacher ratios, 8.9 at elementary and 8.7 at high school; their free/reduced-lunch rates are 28% and 21%, respectively. Because the schools serve different grade spans and are small, comparisons and year-to-year changes should be viewed with care.
Thank you for your feedback!