Summary:
Colony has two schools serving prekindergarten through grade 12: Crest Elementary (PK–8, 185 students) and Crest High (grades 9–12, 78 students). The clearest area-wide concern is science: in 2025–2026, proficiency was 28% at Elementary and 7% at High, compared with 38% statewide.
Crest High stands out in all-grades math, with 47% proficient—6 points above the state rate—while Crest Elementary had 28%, 13 points below the state. Elementary had the stronger all-grades science result, at 28% versus High’s 7%, but both were below the state rate. ELA was closer: High had 41% and Elementary 39%, both below the state’s 46%. At Elementary, grade 7 was a bright spot in ELA and math, exceeding state rates by 13 and 19 points; High’s grade-10 math result was 10 points above the state. Because the schools serve different grade spans, all-grades figures are broad contrasts rather than like-for-like comparisons.
Recent all-grades ELA and math averages improved, but science did not. The equal-school average rose 7 points in ELA and 5 in math from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, while Elementary science fell 11 points; no prior-year High science result is available. SchoolDigger’s ranking percentile declined over the three years shown at both schools: 26 points at Elementary and 27 at High. Attendance is another difference: chronic absenteeism was 27% at High, 9 points above the state, versus 8% at Elementary, 10 points below. High’s reported graduation rate was 100%, 11 points above the state, for a different school year. High also had a lower student–teacher ratio (10.8 versus 13.6) and free/reduced-lunch rate (46% versus 61%); these observations sit alongside mixed academic results and do not explain them.
Thank you for your feedback!