Summary
Bittersweet Elementary School is a PK–5 school with 494 students at 55860 Bittersweet in Mishawaka, IN, part of the Penn-Harris-Madison School Corp. It is a consistently high-performing school: in 2025–2026 it ranked 123rd of 1,015 Indiana elementary schools (88th percentile, 4 stars), after 95th of 1,005 (91st percentile, 5 stars) in 2024–2025 and 81st of 1,011 (92nd percentile, 5 stars) in 2023–2024. Its profile stands out for strong math, very low chronic absenteeism, low per-pupil spending, and the highest student-teacher ratio among nearby comparison schools.
Math is Bittersweet’s clearest strength. Its all-grade math proficiency is 72.20, second only to Horizon Elementary School (73.96) among nearby schools and well above Elsie Rogers Elementary School (62.07), Moran Elementary School (58.97), Elm Road Elementary School (53.64), and Walt Disney Elementary School (45.38). Third-grade math is especially strong at 81.08, 29.18 points above the state. All-grade ELA is 59.64, strong but behind Horizon Elementary School (62.60) and Elsie Rogers Elementary School (61.49); third- and fourth-grade ELA are excellent, while fifth-grade ELA (55.84) is below the district average and behind several nearby peers. Science is Bittersweet’s most persistent relative weakness: all-grade science is 55.56, below the district’s 61.91 and behind Horizon Elementary School (68.42) and Elsie Rogers Elementary School (61.40), though still above the state. Fifth-grade social studies is strong at 59.74, second nearby after Horizon Elementary School (73.73).
Bittersweet’s chronic absenteeism rate is exceptionally low at 5.2%, compared with 8.4% for the district and 16.7% statewide; only Horizon Elementary School is lower nearby at 3.8%. Bittersweet also has the highest student-teacher ratio in the comparison set (21.4) and the second-lowest per-pupil spending ($9,461 in 2023–2024), while its free/reduced lunch rate has risen from 28.46% to 34.01% over two years without disrupting achievement. Compared with schools in the lower-ranked School City of Mishawaka district, Bittersweet’s proficiency levels are far higher, though those comparisons are not perfectly apples-to-apples because of district and grade-range differences. Overall, Bittersweet is a strong choice for families seeking high achievement, excellent attendance, and spending efficiency, with the clearest opportunities for improvement in upper-elementary ELA, science, and managing class size.
Thank you for your feedback!