Summary
Costello School is a 228-student PK–5 school in Lyons, serving families in an area with a varied group of nearby elementary schools. In 2025–26, its all-grades ELA proficiency was 54%, close to the state’s 56% and above the 45% district result; math was 31%, below the state’s 40% but above the district’s 24%. Fifth-grade science was 40%, below both the state and district. The most important finding is that Costello’s results are improving, but ELA is a clearer strength than math, and science remains a concern.
Costello compares well with nearby schools in its own district, but less strongly with the wider nearby group. Its ELA score was 4 points below the nearby-school average of 58%, while six of ten nearby schools scored lower; in math, four scored lower, and Costello’s 31% was 14 points below the nearby average of 45%. Compared with the three nearby schools in Lyons School District 103, Costello was above their average in both ELA (54% versus 43%) and math (31% versus 27%). Fifth-grade science was a weaker local result: among nearby schools with reported scores, Costello exceeded only Otis P Graves Elementary School. Grade 3 math was 50%, close to the state’s 49%; grade 4 and 5 math results were suppressed and cannot be assessed.
Results have risen over two years: ELA gained 22 points from 2023–24 to 2025–26, and math gained 18, narrowing both gaps with the state. Chronic absenteeism fell from 49% in 2022–23 to 30% in 2024–25 and 2025–26, but remained above the state’s 24% and higher than nine of ten nearby schools. SchoolDigger rated Costello at the 44th statewide percentile with 2 stars, compared with the district’s 17th percentile and 1 star. The student–teacher ratio was 8.5 in 2024–25, and 74% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible that year; these are context, not explanations for results. SchoolDigger’s effectiveness ranking for Low Socio Economic Status Students was at the 62nd percentile, above the school’s overall percentile, while its English Language Learner Students ranking fell from the 74th percentile in 2022–23 to the 49th in 2024–25.
Thank you for your feedback!