Summary:
Mattoon CUSD 2 has four schools in Mattoon, Illinois: two elementary schools serving kindergarten through grade 5, one middle school for grades 6–8, and one high school for grades 9–12. In 2025–2026, the elementary schools and middle school reported IAR results, while the high school reported ACT results for grade 11. Across the elementary schools, Arland D Williams Junior Elementary School led overall, but the most striking difference between the schools appears in fifth grade.
Arland had 61% proficiency in all-grades ELA and 42% in math, compared with 51% and 39% at Riddle Elementary School; the gaps were 10 and 3 percentage points. The fifth-grade difference was wider: Arland led Riddle by 26 points in ELA and 16 in math. Riddle stands out in third-grade math, with 59% proficiency, 7 points above Arland and 10 above the state. Mattoon Middle School was below the state in all-grades ELA and math by 4 and 5 points, though its eighth-grade math was 3 points above the state. Mattoon High School was below the state in all three reported grade-11 ACT subjects: by 8 points in ELA and 9 points in both math and science.
Results generally rose from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026 at the K–8 schools: all three improved in ELA, while math rose at Riddle and the middle school but fell 2 points at Arland. Even with rising science results, the average K–8 gap from the state widened from 1 point below to 6 points below. SchoolDigger percentile rankings fell at all four schools, including 9 points at Arland and 19 at the middle school. As context, both elementary schools reported free/reduced lunch eligible for 2024–2025: 69% at Arland and 71% at Riddle; their student-teacher ratios were similar, at 14.3 and 14.5. Attendance also differs: chronic absenteeism was below the state at both elementary schools but above it at the middle and high schools. Mattoon High’s graduation rate was 91%, above the state’s 90%, despite its higher absenteeism.
Thank you for your feedback!