Summary
Tendoy Elementary School is a small K-5 public school in Pocatello, Idaho, serving 221 students in the Pocatello District. With a student-teacher ratio of just 13.8, it has the smallest class sizes among nearby elementary schools, making it an appealing option for families who value personalized attention. However, the school's academic performance has declined steeply in recent years. After earning a 4-star rating and ranking in the 81st percentile of Idaho elementary schools in 2022-23, Tendoy dropped to the 24th percentile and a 1-star rating by 2025-26.
Today, Tendoy's test scores lag behind many of its neighbors. In 2025-26, 5th grade math proficiency was 32.7%, well below the district average of 44.4%, while 5th grade science was also 32.7%, the lowest among nearby schools. English language arts fared better, with 46% proficiency overall, but that still trails schools like Edahow Elementary School (83.9%), Gate City Elementary School (73.9%), and Lewis & Clark Elementary School (52.2%). Edahow, located less than a mile away, offers a particularly striking contrast: it ranks in the 99th percentile statewide, while Tendoy now sits in the bottom quarter. Notably, Tendoy's rising poverty rate (63.8% free/reduced lunch) overlaps with the decline, but nearby Lewis & Clark has a higher poverty rate yet stronger scores, suggesting demographics are not destiny.
There are some positives for parents to consider. Tendoy's 5th grade ELA proficiency reached 50.9%, close to the district average, and scores improve as students progress from 3rd to 5th grade. Chronic absenteeism is 13.5%, better than the district average of 17.9%. The school's small size and low student-teacher ratio remain genuine strengths. Still, the sharp drop in math and science, combined with the gap between Tendoy and higher-performing neighboring schools, points to real challenges ahead. For parents weighing their options, Tendoy offers a caring, small-school environment, but it's worth asking school leaders how they plan to reverse the recent academic slide.
Thank you for your feedback!