Summary:
The Lakeland District in northern Idaho serves 2,017 students across six elementary schools — Garwood Elementary School, John Brown Elementary School, Betty Kiefer Elementary School, Spirit Lake Elementary School, Athol Elementary School, and Twin Lakes Elementary School — all covering roughly PK–5 and ranked 21st among 101 Idaho districts. Overall, these schools beat state averages in Math (49.4% vs. 43.1%) and ELA (60.7% vs. 54.0%), but individual schools differ significantly.
For parents seeking the strongest academic option, John Brown Elementary School is the clear leader. It holds the highest state rank (62nd, 82nd percentile) and has earned 4 stars every ranked year, with 64.5% Math and 64.2% ELA proficiency — far above district and state averages — despite having the highest free/reduced lunch rate (43.0%). Twin Lakes Elementary School posts the district's best 5th-grade science score (61.0%) and remains a solid 4-star school, but its ELA proficiency dropped sharply from 69.0% to 58.0% this year. At the other end, Garwood Elementary School is the biggest concern: its rank fell from 151st to 261st, with the lowest Math (39.5%) and ELA (46.7%) scores in the group, plus a particularly weak 5th-grade cohort (27.0% Math, 25.4% Science).
Betty Kiefer Elementary School is the efficiency standout, spending the least per student ($7,588) while staying consistently in the state's top 100 with 4 stars. Spirit Lake Elementary School has the best attendance record (8.2% chronic absenteeism) and excellent 3rd-grade ELA (69.5%), but a puzzling drop to 44.2% in 4th grade suggests a possible cohort issue. Athol Elementary School sits in the middle, though its high absenteeism rate (17.9%) and below-average scores make it worth watching. Notably, poverty rates do not predict performance here — John Brown Elementary School thrives despite the highest poverty rate, while Garwood Elementary School struggles with a much lower one. For parents, targeted questions about attendance supports and grade-level instruction may be more useful than overall rankings when choosing a school.
Thank you for your feedback!