Summary:
This analysis examines three elementary-level schools in zip code 34772 (Saint Cloud, FL), serving grades PK-5 or K-8 within the Osceola school district, which is ranked in the bottom 20% of Florida districts.
The standout school in this area is Canoe Creek K-8, which earns a 4-star rating and ranks in the top 20% of Florida elementary schools. It dramatically outperforms its peers, achieving 80% math proficiency compared to 67% at Hickory Tree Elementary School and just 45% at Creative Inspiration Journey School Of St Cloud. This success is notable because all three schools have nearly identical rates of students eligible for free/reduced lunch (around 48-49%), showing that poverty is not the primary driver of performance here. Instead, Canoe Creek K-8 benefits from the lowest chronic absenteeism (14.7%) and the lowest student-to-teacher ratio (16.9:1), while Creative Inspiration Journey School Of St Cloud struggles with the highest absenteeism (26.3%) and highest ratio (22:1).
A critical finding is that resources are not aligned with need: the struggling Creative Inspiration Journey School Of St Cloud receives the least funding per student ($8,142), while the top-performing Canoe Creek K-8 receives over $2,000 more ($10,168). Additionally, the K-8 model is not a guarantee of success, as both the best and worst schools in the area share this configuration. For parents, Canoe Creek K-8 is a clear outlier of excellence in a low-performing district, while Hickory Tree Elementary School offers solid middle-ground performance with a 3-star rating.
Thank you for your feedback!