Summary:
In zip code 32809 (Orlando/Belle Isle, FL), four elementary schools serve approximately 3,095 students, presenting a stark contrast between one high-performing charter school and three traditional public schools facing significant challenges.
Cornerstone Academy Charter is the standout school in the area, earning a 4-star rating and ranking in the top 20% of Florida elementary schools (80th percentile). It serves grades K-8 and offers advanced coursework with exceptionally high proficiency rates. In stark contrast, Winegard Elementary is the lowest-ranked school in the zip code (10th percentile, 0 stars), while Sadler Elementary and Lancaster Elementary both rank in the bottom 16% of the state (1 star each). All three traditional schools are part of the Orange school district, which holds a 3-star rating statewide.
A key finding is the "money vs. performance" paradox: Winegard Elementary spends the most per student ($13,108) and has the lowest student-teacher ratio (14.7), yet it is the lowest-performing school. Conversely, Cornerstone Academy spends the least ($8,561) and has the highest student-teacher ratio (18.2), yet it outperforms all others dramatically. Chronic absenteeism perfectly mirrors academic rankings—Cornerstone Academy has an excellent 11.6% rate, while Winegard Elementary's critically high 43.3% rate is a major red flag. Economic disadvantage also varies significantly, with Cornerstone Academy serving 33.36% free/reduced lunch students compared to 57-68% at the other three schools. This creates two distinct educational realities in one zip code: one high-performing charter school and three struggling traditional public schools facing high poverty and absenteeism challenges.
Thank you for your feedback!