Summary
Watergrass Elementary School in Wesley Chapel, FL, is a public school serving 859 students in grades PK-5 within the Pasco district, and it is currently at a critical juncture after a decade of solid performance has given way to a notable decline. While the school has historically been a reliable mid-tier performer, its state ranking has dropped from the 64th percentile to the 39th percentile, earning it a 2-star rating, which stands in stark contrast to several nearby schools that are improving or maintaining high performance. For example, Double Branch Elementary has risen to the 64th percentile, and Academy At The Farm and Pinecrest Academy Wesley Chapel consistently earn 4-star ratings in the 80th-90th percentile range.
A key concern is a "two-speed" academic profile where younger students thrive but older students fall behind. In the most recent school year, 3rd graders outperformed district and state averages in both English Language Arts (67% vs. 61%) and Math (68% vs. 62%), but by 5th grade, proficiency dropped below district and state averages in both subjects, with Science scores a particular weakness (46% vs. 56% district). This pattern is the opposite of high-performing neighbors like Double Branch Elementary, where 5th graders score 69% in ELA and 56% in Math. Additionally, a dramatic one-year drop in 4th grade performance—an 18-point decline in ELA and a 21-point decline in Math between 2023-2024 and 2024-2025—suggests potential issues with instruction or a specific cohort of students.
Chronic absenteeism is a major and growing problem, jumping from 14.7% to 22.6%, which is significantly higher than nearby high-performing schools like Double Branch Elementary (16.9%) and Academy At The Farm (14.9%). Interestingly, the percentage of students eligible for free/reduced lunch has decreased, which typically correlates with improved performance, yet Watergrass is declining, pointing to challenges beyond socioeconomic factors. The school spends $9,616 per student, below the district average, but this alone does not explain the decline, as Double Branch Elementary spends less ($8,949) and performs better. Watergrass is part of a "struggling middle" cluster in Wesley Chapel, losing ground to a "high-performance cluster" of schools, and its leadership must urgently address the 4th-grade slump, improve attendance, and learn from its high-performing peers to reverse the trend.
Thank you for your feedback!