Summary
Homestead Middle School is a public school in Homestead, FL, serving 545 students in grades 6-8 as part of the Miami-Dade district, and it serves a high-poverty community where over 76% of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The school has historically struggled, ranking in the bottom 10-18% of Florida middle schools for the past decade, but it has shown a clear upward trend, climbing from the 5th percentile in 2020-2021 to the 18th percentile in 2025-2026 and earning its first 1-star rating in 2023-2024 after several years of 0-star ratings.
The most critical issue at Homestead Middle School is an extremely high chronic absenteeism rate of 51.2% in 2023-2024, nearly double the district average of 28.2% and significantly higher than the state average of 31.4%. This rate has remained above 46% for five years, peaking at 61.9% during the pandemic, and it is a major barrier to academic achievement. The school also shows a stark contrast in performance: students in advanced courses like Biology 1 and Algebra 1 excel, with proficiency rates of 82% and 68% respectively, often exceeding district averages. However, on core FAST assessments for English Language Arts and Math, proficiency rates are critically low, ranging from 29% to 43%, far below district and state averages of 60-67%. This suggests a "two-track" system where top-tier students thrive while the majority struggle, likely worsened by absenteeism.
Compared to nearby schools, Homestead's challenges are not insurmountable. For example, Herbert A. Ammons Middle School, just 9.36 miles away, is a 5-star school with a 6.9% chronic absenteeism rate and 95%+ proficiency, but it serves a much wealthier community. More tellingly, Somerset Academy Charter Middle School (South Homestead), located just 0.73 miles away with a similar poverty rate of 81.8%, has a much lower absenteeism rate of 33% and outperforms Homestead in nearly every subject. This indicates that Homestead's issues are not solely about poverty but about school-specific factors like culture and attendance management. Despite spending $16,497 per student—substantially higher than nearby peers—the school's high investment is not translating into broad academic success, making chronic absenteeism the primary focus for improvement.
Thank you for your feedback!