Summary
Bradford Elementary School in Starke, FL, serves 745 students from Pre-K through 6th grade in the Bradford district, a high-poverty area where about 68% of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The school has shown a positive trend, climbing from the 12th percentile in 2021-2022 to the 41st percentile (2 stars) in 2025-2026, but it still faces significant challenges, particularly with chronic absenteeism, which has consistently hovered around 40%—far above the state average of 31% and the highest among nearby schools like Starke Elementary (30.5%) and Lawtey Elementary (37.5%). This attendance crisis is a major hurdle that could limit further academic gains.
Academically, Bradford Elementary shows an unusual "U-shaped" pattern, with strengths in 4th and 6th grades but weaknesses in 3rd and 5th grades. For example, in 2025-2026, 4th graders outperformed both the district and state in ELA (66% vs. 61% district, 60% state) and Math (69% vs. 58% district, 65% state), while 6th graders also excelled in ELA (69% vs. 65% district, 62% state). However, 3rd graders struggled in Math (51% vs. 66% state), and 5th graders underperformed in ELA (46% vs. 61% state) and Science (46% vs. 60% state). This inconsistency suggests possible instructional gaps or cohort effects that the school needs to address.
Interestingly, Bradford Elementary is surrounded by schools from the higher-performing Clay district, such as McRae Elementary (64th percentile) and Clay Hill Elementary (62nd percentile), which serve similar poverty rates but consistently outperform Bradford. Even within its own district, Lawtey Elementary—just 8.5 miles away with a smaller enrollment of 257 and lower poverty (55%)—ranks in the 73rd percentile (4 stars), with 6th-grade math proficiency at an astonishing 97% compared to Bradford's 58%. This highlights that smaller school size and a different culture can overcome district-wide challenges, and Bradford's lower per-student spending ($10,920 vs. $12,206 at Starke Elementary) may be a contributing factor to its struggles.
Thank you for your feedback!