Best Elementary Schools in Zip Code 19975

Zip code 19975 (Selbyville, Delaware) is served by two elementary schools—Southern Delaware School of the Arts and Showell (Phillip C.) Elementary School—both part of the Indian River School District, which ranks 10th out of 34 districts in Delaware with a 4-star rating. Together, these schools educate roughly 701 students in grades K-5 (with Southern Delaware School of the Arts extending through 8th grade), and both stand out for their strong attendance and above-average academic performance compared to district and state benchmarks.

The clear academic leader is Southern Delaware School of the Arts, ranked 24th out of 106 Delaware elementary schools (77th percentile) with a 4-star rating. It outperforms the district by 15-30 percentage points in most subjects, with standout results like 72.7% proficiency in 4th grade math (vs. 43.8% district) and 75% proficiency in 5th grade social studies. However, its 8th grade science proficiency is a concern at just 12.8%, and math proficiency dips notably in middle school grades. Showell (Phillip C.) Elementary School ranks 41st (61st percentile, 3-star) and shows more variability—its 5th grade math is excellent at 57.4% proficiency, but 4th grade ELA dropped sharply to 20.5% this year. Showell also spends $2,375 more per student than the arts school, yet achieves lower overall results, suggesting the arts school’s specialized approach and selective admissions may drive its edge.

Both schools share a major strength: chronic absenteeism rates of 10.5% and 11.9%, roughly half the district’s 20.2%, indicating strong family engagement in the Selbyville community. Social studies is a hidden gem at both schools, with 5th grade proficiency at 75% (SDSA) and 67.9% (Showell) versus 61.9% statewide. For parents, this area offers a high-performing arts magnet option and a solid traditional elementary school, both within a well-regarded district—though families should weigh SDSA’s middle school math decline and Showell’s grade-level swings when choosing.