Summary:
Middletown, Delaware is served by 15 schools spanning Pre-K through 12th grade, primarily within the highly-ranked Appoquinimink School District, which holds a 5-star rating and ranks 4th out of 34 districts statewide.
For parents, this area offers a mix of exceptional standouts and more average options. Cedar Lane Elementary School is the clear academic leader among elementary schools, ranking 3rd out of 106 statewide with 4th-grade math proficiency near 80%—double the state average. Waters (Alfred G.) Middle School is the top middle school, ranking 4th out of 59, with 7th-grade social studies proficiency at 87.89%. The highest-performing school overall is MOT Charter School, which achieves top-tier results across all grade levels while spending the least per student ($10,748) and maintaining a chronic absenteeism rate of just 6.5%. Crystal Run Elementary School is a new standout, debuting at 7th out of 106 schools in its first year of ranking. However, not all schools perform equally—Redding (Louis L.) Middle School and Brick Mill Elementary School rank near the 50th percentile, making school choice within the district significant.
Across the board, Middletown schools consistently beat state averages in nearly every subject, with a particular strength in social studies. However, math proficiency declines sharply in upper grades—high school SAT math proficiency falls to just 14-39%. Chronic absenteeism is a concern at the comprehensive high schools: Appoquinimink High School (24.0%) and Middletown High School (22.5%) both exceed the state average, despite maintaining strong graduation rates of 94-97%. St. Georges Technical High School offers a specialized alternative with the lowest dropout rate (1.0%) and excellent attendance. Parents should note that single-year test scores can fluctuate significantly, so multi-year trends are more reliable indicators of school quality.
Thank you for your feedback!