Best Middle Schools in Georgetown, DE

Georgetown, Delaware is home to two middle schools serving grades 6-8 and approximately 1,069 students: the large, established Georgetown Middle School and the much smaller, newer Bryan Allen Stevenson School of Excellence.

For parents, the choice between these two schools is stark. Georgetown Middle School, part of the highly-rated Indian River School District (4-star rating), is the clear academic leader. It consistently earns a 3-star rating and performs near or above state averages in most subjects, with a notable strength in 7th grade where ELA (49.6%) and Math (43.1%) proficiency significantly exceed state averages. Its chronic absenteeism rate (14%) is also better than both the district (20.2%) and state (17.1%). However, the school shows a sharp drop-off in 8th grade across all subjects, and its 8th-grade science proficiency (11.8%) is a critical weakness, well below the state average (16.4%). In contrast, Bryan Allen Stevenson School of Excellence is struggling with a 1-star rating and a staggering student-teacher ratio of 41.6:1—nearly three times higher than Georgetown's 14.5:1. This resource challenge likely contributes to its low proficiency rates, though its 8th-grade ELA score (32.4%) is actually comparable to Georgetown's (30.5%), hinting at untapped potential.

Overall, Georgetown Middle School offers a stable, well-supported environment with consistent performance, making it the safer choice for most families. The Bryan Allen Stevenson School of Excellence faces significant staffing and data gaps (no math or science scores reported), making it a higher-risk option despite its promising 8th-grade ELA results. Parents should weigh Georgetown's proven track record against Stevenson's smaller, emerging program.