Summary:
Glastonbury School District in Connecticut serves two middle schools — Smith Middle School (grades 6–8, 875 students) and Gideon Welles School (grades 5–6, 551 students) — for a combined middle-level enrollment of 1,426 students in a district ranked 24th out of 153 Connecticut districts. Both schools deliver exceptional academic results, with every reported proficiency score landing substantially above the state average, often by 20–30 percentage points.
Smith Middle School has earned a 5-star SchoolDigger rating for three consecutive years, ranked #24 of 258 in 2025–2026, #19 of 252 in 2024–2025, and #20 of 250 in 2023–2024. Gideon Welles School posts a slightly higher overall average proficiency (74.7% vs. 73.1% at Smith), including the single highest subject score in the data set: 80.2% proficient in 5th-grade ELA. Chronic absenteeism is remarkably low at both schools — 4.8% at Smith and 5.5% at Gideon, compared to 6.5% district-wide and 16.4% statewide. Demographics and student-teacher ratios are nearly identical as well, with free/reduced lunch rates of 13.83% and 13.25% and student-teacher ratios of 13.1 and 13.0, respectively.
The most striking anomaly is per-pupil spending: Smith spends $22,456 per student while Gideon spends just $11,633 — a difference of nearly $10,823 per student despite similar demographics, staffing ratios, and outcomes. Also noteworthy is the grade 6 data gap: although Smith serves grade 6, no 6th-grade test scores are reported for the school, making direct overlap comparisons with Gideon incomplete. Gideon's 5th-grade ELA improved notably from 74.5% to 80.2% year over year, while Smith's 8th-grade math jumped from 65.3% to 72.5%. Overall, both Glastonbury middle schools are high-performing, low-absenteeism schools, and the spending disparity is the key item worth investigating for equitable resource allocation.
Thank you for your feedback!