Summary
Bauder Elementary School is a PK-5 school in Fort Collins, CO, serving 423 students as part of the highly rated Poudre School District R-1. Despite sitting in a 5-star district ranked in the 90th percentile statewide, Bauder itself holds a 3-star rating and ranks at the 55th percentile among Colorado elementary schools. In 2025–2026 CMAS testing, Bauder posted 44.5% proficiency in English Language Arts (roughly matching the state average of 44.7%), 41.6% in Math (above the state's 37.3%), and 40.3% in Science (above the state's 36.1%). However, district-wide averages were 60.1% in ELA, 52.2% in Math, and 50.4% in Science, meaning Bauder trails its own district by roughly 10–16 percentage points in every subject.
The school shows some encouraging signs. Its chronic absenteeism rate of 20.6% is well below both the district (30.7%) and state (28.4%), and its student-teacher ratio of 12.4:1 is favorable compared with most nearby schools. Bauder also shows clear academic growth as students advance: 3rd-grade ELA proficiency sits at just 32.8% (far below the district's 55.9%), but by 5th grade it rises to 52.2%, above the state average. Math follows a similar upward trajectory from 35.9% in 3rd grade to 45.6% in 5th grade. The most significant concern, however, is the school's performance with students from low-income families. Results for this group fell to the 29th percentile statewide in 2025–2026, down from the 44th percentile the previous year.
Bauder's biggest challenge is that nearby schools in the same district post significantly stronger results. Dunn Elementary School (65.4% ELA), Johnson Elementary School (70.7% ELA), and Beattie Elementary School (64.3% ELA) all far outpace Bauder's 44.5% ELA proficiency. Even schools with similar or higher poverty rates outperform it: Bennett Elementary School (48.6% free/reduced lunch) exceeds Bauder in both ELA and math, and Harris Bilingual Elementary School, despite a higher poverty rate at 61.1%, also posts stronger scores. Bauder has been stuck in the 3-star range for a decade, never breaking into 4-star territory. For parents, the bottom line is that Bauder offers a favorable student-teacher ratio, healthy attendance, and visible grade-level progress, but its early-literacy gap and recent decline in outcomes for low-income students are areas that deserve attention.
Thank you for your feedback!