Summary:
Byers School District No. 32J is a small rural Colorado district that authorizes 10 schools — 3 elementary, 3 middle, and 4 high schools — split between two traditional brick-and-mortar schools (Byers Elementary School and Byers Junior-Senior High School) and eight statewide online programs. The virtual schools enroll 6,343 of the district's 6,853 students (93%), led by Astravo Online Academy High School with 2,750 students — over 11 times the size of the physical high school. The district ranks 85th of 115 Colorado districts (26th percentile, 1-star), but that figure masks a clear divide: the neighborhood schools perform respectably while the online schools drag the district down.
The standout is Byers Junior-Senior High School, with a 97.6% graduation rate — 12 points above the state and roughly double the 43.8% to 50.4% rates at the four online high schools. It is the district's highest-ranked high school (49th percentile, 2 stars) with a 0.7% dropout rate. Byers Elementary School is the district's best-ranked school overall (62nd percentile, 3 stars), beating the state in ELA (49.2% vs. 44.7%) and math (40.9% vs. 37.3%), including a standout 75% fifth-grade ELA proficiency. It also has the lowest student-teacher ratio (18:1), while every virtual school exceeds 36:1, up to 63.3:1 at Colorado Online Middle School.
The virtual schools lag badly in academics. Math proficiency is in single digits at Astravo Online Academy Middle School (3.4%), Colorado Online Middle School (6.4%), and Colorado Virtual Academy High School (9%). Chronic absenteeism is counterintuitively low online — Colorado Online Middle School reports 2.8% — while Byers Elementary School has the highest rate (14.8%), suggesting the virtual attendance metric may not reflect genuine engagement. The Astravo brand (4,157 students) is the weakest family of schools, while Colorado Online High School has improved from the 10th to 34th percentile. The takeaway for parents is straightforward: the brick-and-mortar schools in this district provide the far stronger education.
Thank you for your feedback!