Best Public Schools in Gypsum, CO

The city of Gypsum, Colorado, is served by 5 public schools within the Eagle County School District No. Re 50—one high school, two elementary schools, and two middle schools—enrolling roughly 2,040 students in a mid-sized mountain community. The district itself ranks as a median performer in Colorado (57th out of 115 districts), and school outcomes vary widely across the city. One notable outlier is World Academy Middle School, which enrolls only 12 students and has no comparable test or ranking data.

Red Hill Elementary School is the clear standout among elementary schools, improving its state rank from the 15th to the 36th percentile over three years and matching or exceeding district averages in ELA and 5th-grade science (39% proficiency). It also has the lowest chronic absenteeism in the city at 25.7% and the most favorable student-teacher ratio at 10.3:1. At the high school level, Eagle Valley High School posts an impressive 91.3% graduation rate—well above the district and state—despite test scores near district averages. In contrast, Gypsum Elementary School ranks in the 9th percentile, with ELA proficiency at just 21.9% and 5th-grade science at only 6.3%, while Gypsum Creek Middle School has the lowest math proficiency in the city at 13.5%.

Math achievement is a citywide weakness, with every school falling well below the state average of 37.3% proficiency. Chronic absenteeism is another major concern, especially at Gypsum Creek Middle School, where 49.4% of students are chronically absent, and at Gypsum Elementary, at 40.6%. The gap between the two elementary schools is striking: Red Hill outperforms Gypsum Elementary by roughly 16 points in ELA, 5 points in math, and nearly 33 points in science, alongside lower poverty rates and absenteeism. For parents, the picture is mixed—Red Hill and Eagle Valley show that strong outcomes are achievable, but the district's priorities should clearly focus on math support, reducing absenteeism, and closing the equity gap between schools.