Summary:
In the rural Cottonwood, CA area (zip code 96022), two public middle schools, West Cottonwood Junior High and Evergreen Middle, serve grades 5-8 with similar student populations, each performing near or above state averages but with distinct academic profiles.
When comparing the two, Evergreen Middle stands out for stronger performance in math and science and a notably lower rate of chronic student absenteeism. West Cottonwood Junior High holds a slight edge in English Language Arts and spends more per student. Both schools serve a significant number of economically disadvantaged students, making their overall performance noteworthy, though each shows concerning dips in student proficiency as children move into the 8th grade.
For parents, the choice may come down to academic priority: a strength in English at West Cottonwood Junior High in the Cottonwood Union Elementary district versus stronger STEM subjects at Evergreen Middle in the Evergreen Union district. The lower absenteeism at Evergreen is also a significant positive indicator of student engagement. The performance trends suggest families at both schools should inquire about support programs for students transitioning to high school.
Thank you for your feedback!