Summary
C. Roy Carmichael Elementary serves 344 students in kindergarten through grade 6 in Portola, California. In 2025–2026, its proficiency rates were below both the state and Plumas Unified in English language arts (ELA), math, and science. The most important concern is that the school trailed the state in every subject, by 19 percentage points in ELA, 19 in math, and 14 in science.
Science is the school’s strongest subject relative to the state and district: its gaps were 14 points below the state and 2 below the district, compared with ELA gaps of 19 and 9 points and math gaps of 19 and 6. ELA is its weakest area against those benchmarks. Compared with nearby Loyalton Elementary, Carmichael also had lower all-grade results in every subject—by 12 points in ELA, 26 in math, and 26 in science. Fourth-grade math is a bright spot within the school: 36% were proficient, compared with 9% in grade 5 and 5% in grade 6. Carmichael’s fourth-grade rate was 6 points below the state, while its fifth- and sixth-grade results were much further behind.
Results have weakened over the longer term in ELA and math: from 2022–2023 to 2025–2026, ELA fell from 38% to 30%, and math from 29% to 19%; science was nearly flat, moving from 23% to 22%. SchoolDigger ranked Carmichael at the 20th percentile with 1 star in 2025–2026, compared with Loyalton at the 59th percentile and 3 stars. Carmichael’s overall percentile has fallen 36 points since 2021–2022. Its SchoolDigger statewide ranking for Low Socio Economic Status Students also dropped, from the 50th percentile in 2023–2024 to the 19th in 2025–2026, close to its overall 20th-percentile standing. In 2024–2025, 71% of Carmichael students were free/reduced lunch eligible, compared with 35% at Loyalton. Carmichael’s 2024–2025 student–teacher ratio was 20.2 students per teacher, versus 23.0 at Loyalton. Chronic absenteeism was also higher: 32% at Carmichael in 2025–2026, compared with 26% in the district, 18% statewide, and 9% at Loyalton.
Thank you for your feedback!