Summary
Old Mill Elementary serves 261 students in grades K–5 in Mill Valley, a Marin County community. In 2025–2026, 75% of students were proficient in English language arts (ELA), 78% in math, and 76% in science—well above state rates in all three subjects. But results fell from the previous year, and third grade stands out as a particular concern: just 58% were proficient in ELA and 64% in math, the lowest third-grade ELA result among nearby schools and tied for the lowest in math. The most important finding is that the latest results show a sharp decline, especially in ELA, alongside a pronounced third-grade weakness.
Compared with nearby K–5 schools, science is Old Mill’s relative bright spot, while ELA is its clearest weakness. Its 76% science proficiency was about 1 point above the comparable-school average; only Edna Maguire Elementary, Park Elementary, and Cove scored higher. In ELA, Old Mill was 5 points below the nearby-school average and 7 points below the Mill Valley Elementary district; among those peers, only Cove scored lower. Math was 2 points below the nearby-school average but essentially level with the district. Against the state, Old Mill was ahead by 26 points in ELA, 40 in math, and 40 in science.
All three subjects ended below their 2022–2023 levels, though the school’s statewide standing remains high. ELA was down 10 points, math 7, and science 4; SchoolDigger ranked Old Mill 506th of 5,804 California schools in 2025–2026, at the 91st percentile with five stars, down from the 99th percentile the year before. In 2024–2025, its student-teacher ratio was 21.7, the highest among nearby schools with reported figures. The school reported 4% free/reduced lunch eligible that year, among the lowest shares in the local comparison; California is identified as a statewide-free-meals state, so this is an eligibility measure, not a measure of access to free meals. Meanwhile, chronic absenteeism improved from 18% in 2022–2023 to 5% in 2025–2026, even as test scores fell.
Thank you for your feedback!