Beta You're viewing our redesigned school page. Prefer the classic layout?

Old Mill Elementary

Public Grades K-5
507th
SchoolDigger Rank ?
of 5,817 California Elementary Schools
Better than 91% of California elementary schools
Summary

Old Mill Elementary serves 261 students in grades K–5 in Mill Valley, a Marin County community. In 2025–2026, 75% of students were proficient in English language arts (ELA), 78% in math, and 76% in science—well above state rates in all three subjects. But results fell from the previous year, and third grade stands out as a particular concern: just 58% were proficient in ELA and 64% in math, the lowest third-grade ELA result among nearby schools and tied for the lowest in math. The most important finding is that the latest results show a sharp decline, especially in ELA, alongside a pronounced third-grade weakness.

Compared with nearby K–5 schools, science is Old Mill’s relative bright spot, while ELA is its clearest weakness. Its 76% science proficiency was about 1 point above the comparable-school average; only Edna Maguire Elementary, Park Elementary, and Cove scored higher. In ELA, Old Mill was 5 points below the nearby-school average and 7 points below the Mill Valley Elementary district; among those peers, only Cove scored lower. Math was 2 points below the nearby-school average but essentially level with the district. Against the state, Old Mill was ahead by 26 points in ELA, 40 in math, and 40 in science.

All three subjects ended below their 2022–2023 levels, though the school’s statewide standing remains high. ELA was down 10 points, math 7, and science 4; SchoolDigger ranked Old Mill 506th of 5,804 California schools in 2025–2026, at the 91st percentile with five stars, down from the 99th percentile the year before. In 2024–2025, its student-teacher ratio was 21.7, the highest among nearby schools with reported figures. The school reported 4% free/reduced lunch eligible that year, among the lowest shares in the local comparison; California is identified as a statewide-free-meals state, so this is an eligibility measure, not a measure of access to free meals. Meanwhile, chronic absenteeism improved from 18% in 2022–2023 to 5% in 2025–2026, even as test scores fell.

261
Students ?
21.7
Student/teacher ratio ?
$27,056
Per pupil spending ?
3.8%
Free/reduced lunch eligible (2024-25) ?
All students in California receive free school meals.
≥ 95%
Kindergartners with all required immunizations (2024-25)
 352 Throckmorton Ave.
       Mill Valley, CA  94941-2640

(415) 389-7727

District: Mill Valley Elementary


Students who attend Old Mill Elementary usually attend:

Middle:    Mill Valley Middle
High:    Tamalpais High
Racial breakdown:

White:
70.1%
Two or more races:
21.5%
Hispanic:
5.7%
more
 See top rated California elementary schools

 Compare Old Mill Elementary to nearby elementary schools!
At a glance
▼ Ranking trend: Declining — 98th percentile in 2015 → 91st in 2026
Strengths
✓Test scores above the California average (76% vs 42% meeting standards)
✓Ranks in the top 9% of California elementary schools
Worth a look
!Ranking has slipped — down 7 percentile points since 2015
!Near the bottom of Mill Valley Elementary's ranking
Students meeting standards (2025-2026) ?
This school76%
District avg79%
California avg42%
507th of 5,817
California public elementary schools ?
Top 9%▼ down 8 pts since 2016
From top 1% (2016) to top 9% (2026)
See the entire ranking list of California Elementary Schools →
★★★★★
SchoolDigger rating ?
5th of 5Elementary Schools in the Mill Valley Elementary
28th of 1,530Mill Valley Elementary among California districts
Statewide rank percentile over time (100 = the top-ranked school in the state; click a legend item to add a student group)
Show full rank history (all student groups)

All Students

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankCalifornia percentileRating
202692.5507 of 581791.3%★★★★★
202597.976 of 585798.7%★★★★★
202497.2143 of 586997.6%★★★★★
202398.099 of 585998.3%★★★★★
202298.650 of 588399.2%★★★★★
201997.878 of 578998.7%★★★★★
201898.629 of 566299.5%★★★★★
201798.360 of 569298.9%★★★★★
201698.527 of 561499.5%★★★★★
201598.0101 of 561198.2%★★★★★
201394.3157 of 553097.2%★★★★★
201292.3270 of 539095.0%★★★★★
201193.6207 of 537796.2%★★★★★
201093.1254 of 531495.2%★★★★★
200995.2146 of 519397.2%★★★★★
200895.7142 of 511397.2%★★★★★
200796.9105 of 511397.9%★★★★★
200697.580 of 481898.3%★★★★★
200594.7242 of 482295.0%★★★★★
200493.3312 of 480993.5%★★★★★

Female

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankCalifornia percentileRating
202691.0519 of 558190.7%★★★★★
202598.041 of 559799.3%★★★★★
202496.6145 of 561297.4%★★★★★
202396.5166 of 560997.0%★★★★★
202297.4106 of 563598.1%★★★★★
201998.034 of 549299.4%★★★★★
201898.224 of 541399.6%★★★★★

Male

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankCalifornia percentileRating
202692.0457 of 560391.8%★★★★★
202596.7126 of 562897.8%★★★★★
202495.8214 of 564396.2%★★★★★
202398.261 of 563898.9%★★★★★
202298.634 of 566399.4%★★★★★
201996.1171 of 551096.9%★★★★★
201898.149 of 543199.1%★★★★★

White

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankCalifornia percentileRating
202680.4385 of 253684.8%★★★★☆
202590.669 of 259897.3%★★★★★
202486.8187 of 265192.9%★★★★★
202390.0107 of 266196.0%★★★★★
202293.327 of 272699.0%★★★★★
201990.486 of 283497.0%★★★★★
201894.412 of 273799.6%★★★★★
How student groups rank statewide ? (each group's percentile vs the same group at other schools — higher is better; the +/- beside each compares the group with this school's overall percentile)
Male (2026)92nd percentile~ school
Female (2026)91st percentile~ school
White (2026)85th percentile-6 vs school
By subject vs California (2025-2026) ?
Mathematics78%+40 vs state
Science76%+40 vs state
English Language Arts/Literacy75%+26 vs state

★
No ratings yet
Be the first to rate Old Mill Elementary and help other families decide.
Rate Old Mill Elementary
Have first-hand experience? A quick rating - and a sentence or two about what stands out (teachers, academics, safety, communication) - helps other families know what to expect.
Takes about a minute. We email you a link to verify your review - your address is never shown publicly.
Tap a star to rate
Reviews
No written reviews yet. If you know this school, be the first to share what stands out.



Schools Near Old Mill Elementary

Ranking:
Map legend
E Elementary M Middle H High A Alternative P Private






Frequently Asked Questions about Old Mill Elementary

Students at Old Mill Elementary are 70% White, 21% Two or more races, 6% Hispanic, 3% Asian.

Students who attend Old Mill Elementary usually go on to attend:

Middle : Mill Valley Middle
High : Tamalpais High

Yes. Old Mill Elementary ranks in the top 8.7% of California elementary schools.

In the 2024-25 school year, 261 students attended Old Mill Elementary.

Rate Old Mill Elementary!



Sign up for updates!

Be the first to know when there is an update for Old Mill Elementary!


Latest California data All new data »
2024–25 school spending data (updated)Nov 2, 2026
2013–14 through 2024–25 immunization rates (updated)Oct 19, 2026
2025–26 attendance data, dropout rates & graduation ratesOct 15, 2026
2025–26 CAST, CSA Spanish & Smarter Balanced Assessments scoresOct 15, 2026


SchoolDigger data sources: National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education, the U.S. Census Bureau and the California Department of Education.

IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS: Not all boundaries are included. We make every effort to ensure that boundaries are up-to-date. But it's important to note that these are approximations and are for general informational purposes only. To verify legal descriptions of boundaries or school locations, contact your local tax assessor's office and/or school district.

Diagnostics