Summary
First Avenue Middle is a grades 6–8 school serving 771 students in Arcadia, California, within Arcadia Unified. In 2025–26, 72% of students were proficient in English language arts (ELA), 64% in math and 54% in science, all well above California rates. The key takeaway is that strong results against the state do not make First Avenue the leading middle school in its district.
ELA is First Avenue’s strongest subject compared with the district: its 72% proficiency rate was about 1 percentage point higher than the district’s. In math and science, it was about 4 and 5 points below district results, respectively, though still about 26 and 18 points above state rates. Among the six nearby schools serving grades 6–8, First Avenue ranked third in all three subjects, behind Richard Henry Dana Middle and Foothills Middle. Compared with the other five schools’ averages, First Avenue was about 8 points higher in ELA, 7 points higher in math and 2 points higher in science.
Recent test-score direction is less favorable than the current levels: from 2022–23 to 2025–26, proficiency fell about 6 points in ELA, 2 in math and 3 in science, while state rates rose; First Avenue’s advantage over the state narrowed by about 9, 5 and 9 points, respectively. SchoolDigger still places the school at the 90th statewide percentile, rank 257 of 2,703, with 5 stars, down from the 95th percentile in 2022–23. Its statewide subgroup rankings also show notable differences: SchoolDigger ranks the school at the 46th percentile for serving White students and the 59th for serving students in special education, compared with the 90th percentile overall; those group rankings fell 19 and 21 percentile points, respectively, from 2023–24. The 2024–25 student-teacher ratio was 24.7, the second highest among nearby schools with reported figures. In that same year, 33% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible, higher than at the other two Arcadia middle schools, which reported 29% and 24%.
Thank you for your feedback!