Summary:
This analysis examines two middle schools in Malvern, Arkansas (zip code 72104), both part of the Malvern School District, which serves grades 5-8 and is ranked 167th out of 251 districts in the state.
Malvern Middle School (grades 7-8) stands out for its exceptional Algebra program, achieving an 85.2% proficiency rate in 2024-2025, far exceeding the state average of 30.9%. However, this success masks a deep crisis: its general 8th-grade math proficiency is just 14.3%, and its overall math score (23.2%) is below the state average (44.1%). The school also shows significant ranking volatility, fluctuating between 1-star and 2-star ratings over three years. In contrast, Wilson Intermediate School (grades 5-6) faces a "6th Grade Math Cliff," where proficiency drops from 31.8% in 5th grade to just 18.5% in 6th grade. Both schools serve a high percentage of low-income students (free/reduced lunch rates of 76-78%) and score below state averages in all core subjects, including English Language Arts (Wilson 29.9%, Malvern 27.5% vs. state 39.4%) and Science (Wilson 31.7%, Malvern 25.5% vs. state 44.0%).
A key paradox is resource allocation: Malvern Middle School has a much lower student-teacher ratio (9.3:1 vs. 17:1) and higher per-student spending ($15,859 vs. $13,693) than Wilson Intermediate School, yet its overall test scores are not meaningfully better and are often worse. This suggests that the additional resources at Malvern Middle are not translating into broad academic gains, possibly due to a focus on the advanced Algebra track. The year-over-year instability in performance at both schools, including a drop in Malvern Middle's Science proficiency from 32.9% to 25.5% in one year, indicates a lack of consistent instructional practices across the district.
Thank you for your feedback!