Summary:
The Springdale School District in Arkansas is home to two large high schools, Har-Ber High School and Springdale High School, both serving grades 9-12 with similar enrollments of around 2,200 students, yet they present a stark contrast in academic performance and student demographics.
Har-Ber High School is the clear standout, consistently outperforming its counterpart across all subjects. For the 2025-2026 school year, Har-Ber’s English Language Arts proficiency (37.9%) was double that of Springdale High (18.8%), and its Biology proficiency (31.8%) nearly doubled Springdale’s 16.6%. Har-Ber also boasts a higher graduation rate (92.4% vs. 87.6%) and a significantly lower dropout rate (1.9% vs. 3.8%). In contrast, Springdale High School faces severe challenges, ranking in the bottom 10th percentile of Arkansas high schools with a 0-star rating, while Har-Ber has improved to the 52nd percentile (3 stars). A critical weakness in math is evident at both schools, but it is acute at Springdale High, where 0% of students scored proficient in Algebra and only 6.5% in Geometry, compared to Har-Ber’s 17.1% in Geometry.
A key finding is the "spending paradox": Springdale High actually spends $1,788 more per student ($13,873 vs. $12,085) and has a slightly lower student-teacher ratio (12.7 vs. 13.3) than Har-Ber, yet its outcomes are dramatically worse. This suggests the primary challenge is not funding but the high concentration of poverty, with 85.86% of Springdale High students qualifying for free/reduced lunch versus 58.96% at Har-Ber. The district’s average test scores are heavily masked by Har-Ber’s performance, hiding the fact that Springdale High is struggling at half the proficiency level. These two schools are on divergent trajectories, with Har-Ber improving and Springdale High declining, indicating the achievement gap within the same district is likely to widen.
Thank you for your feedback!