Summary:
Zip code 36608 in Mobile, Alabama, is home to two middle schools serving grades 6-8: ClarkShaw Magnet School and Acceleration Preparatory Academy, which represent two vastly different educational experiences within the same community.
For parents exploring school options, the contrast between these two schools could not be more pronounced. ClarkShaw Magnet School, part of the Mobile County district, is an elite performer that has consistently ranked in the top 5% of all Alabama middle schools for three consecutive years, earning a 5-star rating. Its students dramatically outperform state averages in every subject and grade level—for example, 90.6% of 6th graders are proficient in English compared to the state's 56.8%, and even its weakest area (8th grade math at 40.8% proficiency) still beats the state average by 14 points. In stark contrast, Acceleration Preparatory Academy, operating under MAEF Public Charter Schools, ranks in the bottom 7% of the state with a 0-star rating, falling 30-40 percentage points below state averages in nearly every subject. The achievement gap is extreme: in 8th grade math, ClarkShaw's proficiency rate is 54 times higher than Acceleration's 0.8%.
Socioeconomic factors and attendance tell an important part of the story. Acceleration serves a higher-need population with 83.5% of students qualifying for free/reduced lunch, compared to 48.1% at ClarkShaw. However, both schools have remarkably low chronic absenteeism (2.7% at ClarkShaw and 5.7% at Acceleration versus the 12% state average), indicating students at both schools are showing up consistently. This suggests the performance gap stems from academic programming and resources rather than attendance issues. For families in 36608, the choice between these two schools represents a decision between a selective magnet model producing elite results and an open-enrollment charter serving a higher-need population—a choice with vastly different outcomes.
Thank you for your feedback!