Summary
J F Shields High School is a small, rural public school in Beatrice, AL, serving 179 students in grades PK through 12 within the Monroe County school district, where 81% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
This school tells two very different stories depending on the grade level. In 3rd grade, students are thriving—73% scored proficient in math, which is more than double the district average and well above the state average. However, that early success dramatically fades as students get older. By 8th grade, math proficiency drops to just 6%, and by 11th grade, it falls to 0%—a trend that has persisted for four straight years. English shows a similar pattern: 3rd graders outperform the state average, but by 11th grade, only 6% are proficient. This "middle school cliff" suggests the school excels at teaching foundational skills but struggles to keep students on track as coursework becomes more challenging. With a student-teacher ratio of 11.9:1, class sizes are small, yet the academic slide in upper grades remains a serious concern.
On a positive note, chronic absenteeism has been improving, dropping from 17.7% to 14.5% over the past few years, now better than the district average. The graduation rate, however, has been volatile, recently sitting at 84%—below the state's 88.2%. The school spends a substantial $12,786 per student, reflecting the high cost of running a small rural school, but that investment hasn't yet translated into high school success. For parents, the key takeaway is that J F Shields shows real strength in early elementary years, but families should be aware of the significant academic challenges that emerge in middle and high school, and may want to explore what additional support is available for older students.
Thank you for your feedback!