Summary:
The Colbert County school district in Alabama serves about 2,573 students across 8 schools—5 elementary schools (PK-6) and 3 high schools (7-12)—with no standalone middle schools, and it ranks 72nd out of 139 districts statewide with a 2-star rating.
If you're looking at elementary options, New Bethel Elementary School is the clear standout, ranking in the 94th percentile statewide (44th out of 686) with a 5-star rating for three straight years. Its 4th grade English proficiency hits 94.4% and science reaches 88.9%—both roughly 35-40 points above state averages. It also has the district's lowest chronic absenteeism (7.1%) and lowest poverty rate (43.4% free/reduced lunch). Hatton Elementary School is a strong second choice, ranking in the 69th percentile despite having the second-highest poverty rate (65.3%), proving that demographics don't dictate outcomes. Cherokee Elementary School sits mid-pack (62nd percentile), while Colbert Heights Elementary School and Leighton Elementary School lag behind, with Leighton ranking in the 33rd percentile and math proficiency nearly 11 points below state averages.
For high schools, Colbert Heights High School is the best option, ranking in the 61st percentile with a 98.5% graduation rate (7 points above state) and strong 11th grade English (35.7%) and science (36.6%) scores. Cherokee High School is more volatile—it improved dramatically in 11th grade math (from 3.6% to 18.8% in one year) but struggles with chronic absenteeism at 23.7%. Colbert County High School is the biggest concern, ranking in the 31st percentile with just 9.6% of 11th graders proficient in English and a graduation rate of 89.4%. Across all high schools, 11th grade math is a universal weakness (16.9-18.8% vs. 27.2% state), and the transition from elementary to 7th grade shows a sharp drop-off in scores—a key area for parents to watch.
Thank you for your feedback!