Summary:
The five high schools in Marshall County, Alabama, serve a mix of grades 6-12 and 9-12, with enrollments ranging from just 71 students at Marshall County Online School to 727 at Douglas High School, and the district overall ranks in the 30th percentile statewide.
Kate D Smith DAR High School is the clear standout, earning a 4-star rating with the district's highest graduation rate (94.3%), an exceptional 1.0% chronic absenteeism rate, and the strongest 11th-grade test scores in math, science, and English. Brindlee Mountain High School is a consistent mid-tier performer with a 3-star rating, and it actually beats the district average in 11th-grade English (36.36% proficiency) despite having the lowest per-student spending. Douglas High School has slipped from the 68th to 44th percentile in one year, with English proficiency dropping sharply to 24.54%. Asbury High School shows a dramatic collapse in 11th-grade math, falling from 19.74% to just 2.86% proficiency, and its 8th-grade math proficiency is 0%. Marshall County Online School struggles most, ranking in the 12th percentile with only 3.03% math proficiency, though it reports 0% chronic absenteeism.
Every school in the district falls below the state average in 11th-grade math, indicating a systemic challenge. Schools with lower free/reduced lunch rates, like Kate D Smith DAR (42.74%), tend to perform better than those with higher rates, such as Marshall County Online (77.46%) and Asbury (72.53%). Brindlee Mountain's 83.1% graduation rate is notably below the state average of 91.5%, while Kate D Smith DAR and Asbury both exceed it. For parents, Kate D Smith DAR High School offers the strongest overall academics and attendance, while Brindlee Mountain High School provides solid English instruction despite resource constraints. Families considering Asbury High School or Marshall County Online School should be aware of significant math proficiency challenges that may require additional support.
Thank you for your feedback!