Summary:
The city of Orrville, Alabama, is served by the Dallas County school district and contains just two schools: Keith MiddleHigh School (grades 6-12, 188 students) and Salem Elementary School (grades PK-5, 155 students), serving roughly 343 students in a predominantly economically disadvantaged area where 78-90% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch.
The two schools present contrasting stories. Keith MiddleHigh School has experienced a catastrophic decline, falling from the 36th percentile (2 stars) in 2023-2024 to the bottom 1% (0 stars) in 2025-2026. Its academic proficiency is alarmingly low, with 0% proficiency in 6th and 7th grade math, 11th grade English, and 11th grade science. Despite this, the school boasts an exceptionally low chronic absenteeism rate of just 3.5% (compared to 17.2% district and 12.0% state) and a respectable 89.4% graduation rate, suggesting students attend but are not learning. In contrast, Salem Elementary School has declined more modestly (from 32nd to 15th percentile) and maintains a 1-star rating. Its 3rd grade math proficiency (50%) actually exceeds the state average (44.9%), but proficiency plummets dramatically by 4th grade (9.1%) and 5th grade (10.5%), indicating a significant drop-off in instructional quality or support after 3rd grade.
Both schools struggle with English Language Arts, with proficiency rates running 26-43 percentage points below state averages across all grades. Chronic absenteeism is a major issue at Salem Elementary (21.8%, nearly double the state rate) but remarkably low at Keith MiddleHigh (3.5%). Resource allocation also raises questions: Keith MiddleHigh spends $14,621 per student versus $11,997 at Salem, yet produces far worse outcomes. The Dallas County district ranks in the bottom 8% statewide, and with small cohorts of 20-30 students per grade, results can be volatile, but the consistent underperformance across multiple grades and subjects indicates systemic challenges rather than statistical anomalies.
Thank you for your feedback!