Summary
Conestoga Elementary in Gillette serves 348 students in grades K–6, among a group of nearby elementary schools in the area. In 2025–26, its average proficiency was 52% in ELA, 60% in math and 50% in science, below nearby-school averages of 56%, 63% and 53%, respectively. The most important takeaway is that Conestoga’s overall results trail the nearby-school average in all three subjects.
Math is the school’s strongest subject compared with state and district results, while fourth grade is a notable weak spot. Overall math proficiency was just 1 point below the state average and 2 points below the district average; fifth-grade math reached 63%, above the state, district and nearby-school averages by 2, 3 and 3 points. Sixth-grade math was also strong at 62%, 5 points above the state and 2 above the district. By contrast, fourth-grade ELA was 43%—9 points below the state, 5 below the district and 8 below nearby schools. Fourth-grade math was 55%, 8 points below the state and 7 below the district. Fourth-grade science was 50%, compared with 56% statewide and 53% at nearby schools.
Results have improved unevenly: from 2022–23 to 2025–26, ELA rose 5 points to 52% and math rose 4 points to 60%, while fourth-grade science fell 6 points to 50%. Conestoga’s SchoolDigger ranking was 98th of 148 schools, at the 34th percentile and 2 stars in 2025–26; that percentile was unchanged from the prior year and below the nearby-school average of 48. Its 2024–25 student-teacher ratio was 10.3, second-lowest among nearby schools, and 41% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible that year, versus a nearby average of 48%. SchoolDigger’s subgroup rankings show a notably stronger comparative result for Hispanic students: 83rd percentile in 2023–24, compared with 31st for the school overall that year. For Special Education Students, the ranking rose from the 26th percentile in 2023–24 to the 45th in 2025–26, 11 points above the school’s overall percentile.
Thank you for your feedback!