Summary:
The six schools in Johnson County School District #1 serve 1,137 students across elementary, middle, high school, and alternative settings. Overall results are strong at some schools but vary notably by school and grade; the most important takeaway is that a schoolwide impression can hide very different outcomes for students in different grades.
Clear Creek Middle School and Buffalo High School stand out for results above state figures. In 2025–2026, Clear Creek exceeded the state in every reported ELA and math grade, including grade 8 by 19.4 points in ELA and 26.4 in math; Buffalo was 13.9–15.8 points above the state in ELA and 19.4–25.5 points above in math. By contrast, Kaycee School had sharply mixed results: grade 4 math was under 20%, versus 62.6% statewide, while its grade 8 ELA and math were each at least 80%. Cloud Peak Elementary was also mixed, with grade 5 ELA and math above state results but grade 3 and 4 ELA below. SchoolDigger ranked Clear Creek 6th of 76 middle schools and Buffalo 9th of 81 high schools; Cloud Peak ranked 72nd of 148 elementary schools.
Recent results show a modest overall gain, but not a uniform upward trend: across matched results for Buffalo, Clear Creek, and Cloud Peak, the average margin over state results grew from 9.1 to 10.4 points. Buffalo made notable grade 10 gains, while Cloud Peak’s grade 4 ELA fell 16.9 points; Kaycee’s results also shifted sharply between years. SchoolDigger’s rankings place Clear Creek at the 92nd percentile and Buffalo at the 89th, compared with Cloud Peak at the 51st. Context also differs: Buffalo has 317 students and an 11.8 student-teacher ratio, while Kaycee has 115 students and a 5.9 ratio; their reported free/reduced-lunch shares are 24.0% and 37.4%, respectively, observations that do not explain achievement. Graduation rates add another contrast: Kaycee’s was 100.0%, compared with 78.6% at New West High School. Some Kaycee test results are reported only as bounds, so exact comparisons are unavailable.
Thank you for your feedback!