Summary:
Zip code 26726, encompassing Keyser, West Virginia, is served by two elementary schools within the Mineral County Schools district, both educating students from Pre-Kindergarten through 4th grade, yet they present vastly different academic outcomes.
Fountain Primary School is the clear standout, ranking 85th out of 355 West Virginia elementary schools with a 4-star rating. It has shown remarkable improvement, jumping 115 positions in a single year. Its students significantly outperform district and state averages, with 61.1% proficient in math and 58.3% in ELA, compared to state averages of 39.4% and 47.6%, respectively. In contrast, Keyser Primary School ranks 330th out of 355 schools with a 0-star rating, and its proficiency rates are roughly half of Fountain's—34.4% in math and 30.0% in ELA. Keyser's 4th grade ELA proficiency is critically low at just 21.4%, less than half the state average.
Both schools operate with nearly identical per-student spending (around $13,400-$13,800) and similar student-teacher ratios (12.0:1 and 12.6:1), making the performance gap particularly striking. Fountain's smaller enrollment of 123 students versus Keyser's 568 may play a role, but the data suggests school-specific factors like instructional quality and culture are driving the disparity. Interestingly, Fountain shows a significant drop-off from 3rd to 4th grade, with proficiency falling by roughly 40 percentage points in math and 33 in ELA, possibly indicating a more rigorous 4th grade curriculum or a particularly strong 3rd grade cohort. For parents, this zip code offers a stark choice: a high-performing, smaller school in Fountain, or a larger school in Keyser that is struggling systemically and pulling down the district's overall metrics.
Thank you for your feedback!