Summary:
Zip code 26257, encompassing the Coalton, WV area, is home to just one elementary school, Coalton Elementary School, which serves grades PK through 5 with a small student body of 156.
As the only school in the area, Coalton Elementary School presents a mixed picture for parents. On the positive side, the school offers a favorable 13.5:1 student-teacher ratio and spends a substantial $12,006 per student, indicating a strong investment in resources. However, academic performance is a significant concern. The school has seen a rapid decline in its state ranking, falling from the 19th percentile in 2023-2024 to the 1st percentile in 2025-2026, earning a 0-star rating. Proficiency rates are well below state averages, with only 16% of students proficient in math and 22.7% in English Language Arts, compared to state averages of 39.4% and 47.6%, respectively. The most alarming data point is the 5th grade math proficiency rate of just 2.9%, a dramatic drop from the 4th grade rate of 36.8%, which actually exceeds the district average. This inconsistency suggests potential issues with curriculum alignment or instructional quality between grade levels. Science scores also plummeted from 34.6% to 11.8% year-over-year.
While the school operates within the Randolph County Schools district, which itself ranks in the 6th percentile statewide, Coalton's performance is notably lower than the district average in most subjects. The disconnect between high per-student spending and low outcomes points to deeper systemic challenges rather than a lack of resources. For parents, this data suggests that while the school provides a small, community-focused environment with individual attention, urgent academic intervention is needed to reverse the downward trend and address the severe proficiency gaps, particularly in 5th grade math.
Thank you for your feedback!