Summary:
Zip code 26170, serving the Saint Marys area of West Virginia, is home to 2 schools within the Pleasants County Schools district, which is ranked 20th out of 54 districts in the state with a 3-star rating.
For parents, the standout story here is St. Marys High School, which has shown dramatic improvement after a volatile few years. The school swung from a 73rd percentile ranking in 2023-2024, down to the 37th percentile in 2024-2025, and then surged to its best-ever showing at the 86th percentile in 2025-2026. This year, the high school posted strong results in English Language Arts (63.9% proficient, 12.7 points above the state) and Science (31.9% proficient, 8.3 points above the state), though math remains a concern at just 22.2% proficiency. The school also boasts a perfect 100% graduation rate, well above the state average of 92.8%. Meanwhile, St. Marys Elementary School excels in 4th grade math with a 76.9% proficiency rate, far exceeding district and state averages, but struggles with 3rd grade English Language Arts at just 27.5% proficiency—17 points below the state. This 49-point gap between the school's best and worst subject-grade combinations is striking.
Both schools share nearly identical student-teacher ratios (13.2:1 at the high school, 13.1:1 at the elementary), suggesting favorable class sizes. The high school's across-the-board improvement of 7-11 percentage points in a single year points to systemic changes rather than random variation, though small class sizes (roughly 77 students per grade) can amplify year-to-year swings. Overall, this area offers a high school with strong recent momentum and a perfect graduation rate, paired with an elementary school that shines in math but needs attention in early literacy. The absence of free/reduced lunch data limits socioeconomic analysis, but the district's consistent performance—with the high school's scores exactly matching district averages—indicates these two schools are the primary drivers of the district's solid 3-star rating.
Thank you for your feedback!