Summary:
The city of Mallory, West Virginia, is served by two public schools within the Logan County Schools district: Man Middle School (grades 5-8) and Man Elementary School (grades PK-4), both of which are rated as 1-star schools in a district ranked 46th out of 54 in West Virginia.
These two schools present a fascinating contrast in academic strengths. Man Elementary School is a clear standout in mathematics, with an all-grades proficiency rate of 42.1% that not only beats the district average of 27% but also exceeds the state average of 39.4%. However, this same school struggles with English Language Arts, posting a 34.1% proficiency rate. Conversely, Man Middle School shows the opposite pattern: its overall ELA proficiency of 43.2% is stronger, but its math proficiency drops to just 20.3%. The middle school also has a notable bright spot in 8th-grade ELA, where 55.1% of students are proficient—far above both district and state averages—suggesting a highly effective teacher or program at that specific grade level.
There are several important takeaways for parents. First, math proficiency at the middle school declines sharply as students advance, falling from 29% in 5th grade to just 16.7% in 8th grade, indicating a critical need for intervention. Second, Man Middle School spends more per student ($13,583) than the elementary school ($12,439), yet its overall test scores are lower, suggesting the extra funding is not translating into better outcomes. Finally, the middle school's state ranking has been stagnant for three years (126th, 125th, 126th), showing consistency but no improvement. While neither school is a top performer, the elementary school's exceptional math program and the middle school's 8th-grade ELA success are genuine strengths worth noting.
Thank you for your feedback!