Summary:
Schools in Bayfield, Wisconsin, a small city served by the Bayfield School District, consist of three public schools — Bayfield Elementary (PK–5), Bayfield Middle (6–8), and Bayfield High (9–12) — serving 404 students in a district ranked 419 of 432 Wisconsin districts, at the 3rd percentile with 0 stars.
For families comparing schools, Bayfield High stands out for completion: a 96.5% graduation rate versus the state’s 92.0% and a 0.8% dropout rate versus 1.1%. It also has the lowest student-teacher ratio, 7.7, and the lowest free/reduced lunch rate, 46.22%. Yet its chronic absenteeism is 58.0%, more than three times the state’s 17.3%, and ACT math proficiency is 12.5% versus 42.93%. Bayfield Middle is the academic bright spot: math improved in grades 6, 7, and 8 from 2024–25 to 2025–26, and 8th grade math, at 40.91%, is the district’s highest math score, though still below state. Bayfield Elementary faces the biggest challenges: the highest free/reduced lunch rate, 64.02%, and highest per-pupil spending, $31,364, but 4th grade math proficiency is 0% versus the state’s 52.87%, while 4th grade ELA and science are both 3.85% and social studies is 19.23%. A bright spot is 3rd grade ELA, which rose from 4% to 42.86%.
Across all three schools, chronic absenteeism is a major red flag: Bayfield Elementary 38.7%, Bayfield Middle 45.7%, Bayfield High 58.0%, district 45.9%, and state 17.3%. High school scores also slipped in comparable subjects, with social studies falling from 39.13% to 32.14%, ACT ELA from 42.86% to 33.33%, and ACT Science from 35.71% to 25%. In 2025–26, Bayfield Elementary ranks in the 8th percentile with 0 stars, Bayfield Middle in the 14th percentile with 1 star, and Bayfield High in the 16th percentile with 1 star. Overall, Bayfield’s strongest metrics are high school graduation/dropout and middle school math improvement; its biggest concerns are district-wide chronic absenteeism, elementary proficiency, high school ACT math, and a district ranking near the bottom of Wisconsin.
Thank you for your feedback!