Summary:
ZIP code 98282 contains two K–5 elementary schools on Camano Island—Utsalady Elementary and Elger Bay Elementary—serving 767 students together within the Stanwood-Camano School District.
Utsalady Elementary is the stronger school overall based on its 2025–26 ranking, three-star rating, and academic results. It ranked 538th of 1,138 Washington elementary schools, compared with 621st for Elger Bay Elementary. Utsalady led in English Language Arts, 48.44% to 44.32%, and science, 60% to 58.62%. Its standout result was fifth-grade ELA, where 61.67% of students were proficient—above both district and state results. Utsalady also reported somewhat lower free/reduced-price lunch participation, higher per-student spending, and a slightly lower student-teacher ratio. The district itself ranks in the 67th percentile statewide, offering a relatively solid broader school-system context.
Elger Bay Elementary has important strengths, especially in math and recent improvement. Its overall math proficiency was narrowly higher than Utsalady’s, 45.76% versus 45.45%, and its third-grade math result was particularly strong at 60.38%, above district and state levels. However, performance was uneven: fifth-grade math was only 27.59%, while ELA remained below both district and state averages. Elger Bay made larger year-over-year gains than Utsalady, including a 10.50-point increase in math and a 7.87-point increase in science, helping its ranking rise sharply. For families comparing the schools, Utsalady offers stronger and more consistent overall results, while Elger Bay shows promising momentum but greater variation by grade. Science is the clearest shared strength, and ELA—along with fifth-grade math at Elger Bay—deserves the closest attention.
Thank you for your feedback!